Skip to main content

Rise of a Disputing Task force: What Exactly is Showing?

Most of the time, people talk about fiction writing as a process of “showing” the readers what the writer sees in her imagination. Is this true altogether? How much showing do you really do in your writing and how much does a reader expect? That’s what we discuss in this blog post. If any professional writer is reading this, I would really appreciate his/her comment in this regard.

There was a forum post I came across recently. In the post, the author had told about a particular novel he read. A best-seller. “Two Americans sat in the café” was the sentence he talked about. And he argued that he couldn’t see those two Americans. There was actually nothing more to show the readers those two Americans.

In order to show the readers them, the writer could have used something like “Two tall, close-shaved, lean sturdy men, one in black jacket and the other in blue were sipping black coffe, sitting opposite each other in the whitewashed square Spanish café. And they carried themselves with such proud that distinguishes Americans from the world.”

Still the sentences don’t show anyone that they are Americans, do they? They may well be British or Australians. How then can you show to your readers two Americans? There is absolutely no way for that. There is no particular characteristic distinguishing an American from the world. There is no particular way of dressing or facial expression that only an American possesses. So, showing your readers Americans is outright impossible. So, what you can’t show, you tell, and the writer did exactly that, without any flamboyancy or wasting space.

Now, here is the first paragraph from John Grisham’s highly successful novel, The Firm.

“The senior partner studied the resume for the hundredth time and again found nothing he disliked about Mitchell Y. McDeere, at least not on paper. He had the brains, the ambition, the good looks. And he was hungry; with his background, he had to be. He was married, and that was mandatory. The Firm had never hired an unmarried lawyer, and it frowned heavily on divorce, as well as womanizing and drinking.”

There is not one sentence that shows you anything. Here I have another piece from Misery by Stephen King.

“As time passed, he became aware that there were periods of non-pain, and that these had a cyclic quality. And for the first time since emerging from the total blackness which had prologued the haze, he had a thought which existed apart from whatever his current situation was. This thought was of a broken-off piling which had jutted from the sand at Revere Beach.”

How much of this is showing to readers? This example is a blend of showing and telling, and the first is mostly telling. Does that mean that they are inept writers, unable to show to their readers what they mean? Not at all. Good writers tell good stories in the most natural way that may or may not include showing.

When I wrote a short story for the first time, the reviews I got included that I was telling the story to the readers more than showing, which I should have done. Here is a piece from an old story of mine.

“However, I don’t think that was enough for me to receive a phone call from a rather obscure science and technology research center in Nevada in the night of 20 December 2005. The man with the coarse and raspy voice that spoke to me told me that his name was Dr. Michael Hahn and he was the director of the sub-atomic research center in the Nevada Institute of Technology, NIT. I looked at the clock on the wall and it said 11:30. I was annoyed at the call and tried amicably to know what he wanted to talk about.”

This is very normal, and nowhere have I faulted from directly telling the story that came to my mind. Being flamboyant with your writing is one thing, and writing normally is quite another. The fact is there is absolutely no such rule as “show your readers.” The only rule in fiction writing is “write with good grammar and punctuation, without which you cannot get published.” Beyond that, success or failure is determined by the style of the writer, the story idea, characterization, dialogs, and many other factors.

Being Flamboyant: A Mistake

If your desire to be extremely flamboyant in your writing to show a situation to the readers is inescapable, that kind of showing not only takes more space, but also wastes a lot of energy. And one important rule of writing is never to tell the readers what is not important. Give them only what can take the story to significant twists. For instance, in a situation you describe about two people, talking sitting in a park bench, you needn’t ever tell “there were blue cars parked in front of the hotel across the street.”

If you wish to intersperse your telling with some showing, then the best means is not interleaving showing snippets like this which don’t stir one bit the storyline, but being more creative with your words, without losing the semantics.

So, good writers write what is important, with some creativity with their words. Above average writers, at least omit what are unimportant. It is the inept writers, who intersperse their writing with all the unimportant things just to be showy or find ridiculous new meanings for their words. You should read this post about semantics of words to find some examples of this kind.

So the whole point here is directly telling the readers your story in your own words, and inserting poetic words and usages only at places that require it. This way, you can show justice to your readers and be loyal to your job.

I call for a discussion in this topic. If you believe against this idea, please post your comments here. If possible, please promote this discussion with the social networking tools. That’s why I put the name as a “Disputing Task Force,” disputing the long-set rule in fiction writing.

History Today

Dante Alighieri, the foremost Italian Poet, and creator of The Divine Comedy was born in 1265.

Copyright © Lenin Nair 2008

Comments

  1. I definitely have an issue with showing vs. telling. Like you've argued, there's nothing wrong with telling when it's done well. I'm tired of other student writers critiquing my work with "Show don't tell" just because a professor has drilled that mantra into their heads.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Comments are moderated very strictly

Popular posts from this blog

En Dash, Em Dash, and Hyphen

We have three types of dashes in use: The hyphen, En Dash, and the Em Dash. In this post, we will see how to use them all correctly. Hyphen (-) The hyphen is the minus key in Windows-based keyboards. This is a widely used punctuation mark. Hyphen should not be mistaken for a dash . Dash is different and has different function than a hyphen. A hyphen is used to separate the words in a compound adjective, verb, or adverb. For instance: The T-rex has a movement-based vision. My blog is blogger-powered. John’s idea was pooh-poohed. The hyphen can be used generally for all kinds of wordbreaks . En Dash (–) En Dash gets its name from its length. It is one ‘N’ long (En is a typographical unit that is almost as wide as 'N'). En Dash is used to express a range of values or a distance: People of age 55–80 are more prone to hypertension. Delhi–Sidney flight was late by three hours. In MS Word, you can put an En Dash either from the menu, clicking Insert->Symbol or by the k

4 Effective Ways to Write About a Boring Topic

  With the plethora of interesting topics to write about, you’re fortunate enough to get the “boring” one. While it can be a pain for many writers to wind up with such a task, I’m telling you now there are ways to make yours more interesting than it is. So if you find yourself stuck with the dreariest topic to fill in a blog about, don’t fret. Here are the four best ways to unburden yourself. 1. Never a boring topic, only a boring writer. Here’s the hard fact: It’s never about the topic being boring. It’s about the writer making it boring. For instance, you’re supposed to write about aquariums. I know, how can you continuously make this topic interesting, right? Well, you’d be surprised just in how many ways you can make it an enticing read. Start by listing down the basic “what”, “where”, “when” and “how” surrounding the topic. You can ask (and research) about “What material was first used to make aquariums?” or even “How the first aquarium was built?” or “What are

5 Simple Ways To Improve Your Writing

As writers, we’re always pushing the envelope to express ourselves better than we did before. However there are times when we plateau, when our writing just doesn’t feel natural. Worse yet, there are times when we can’t get a good paragraph out. Those are times when we start thinking about pushing ourselves and our writing. When you need to tweak and boost your writing up a notch, it’s always good to try something constructive.  For those who could use a couple of tips, here are a few that are sure to help improve your writing and keep it from going stale. 1.Imitate Different Authors If you read other writers for inspiration, why not actively imitate their writing? Once you walk in another writer’s shoes for a bit, writing as they write, you get an idea on how to approach writing about things in ways you normally wouldn’t.  Moreover, it will force you to pay attention to what makes someone else’s writing style unique which, in turn, will help you find ways to make your